Starmer was unprepared | Former Cabinet Secretary, Simon Case Exclusive Interview
Video Overview & Insights
Simon Case, the former Cabinet secretary, served under David Cameron, Theresa May, Boris Johnson, Liz Truss, Rishi Sunak and Sir Keir Starmer, and knows exactly why all of them ended up failing.
Of course, Simon Case's assessment of the PMs is based not on their qualities as leaders of the nation but as implementers of the agenda set by the Civil Service. As leaders, they were all disasterous.
Lord Case’s descriptions of each of the prime ministers he worked for sums up the themes of our interview: Cameron was “a decisive team player”; May “decent but trapped”; Johnson an “amazing communicator” but “a flip-flopping decision-maker”; Truss “too short-lived to tell”; Sunak a “decent, detailed decision-maker” and Starmer “unprepared and apolitical”.
Read more: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/06/26/simon-case-interview-burnham-downing-street/
How can a hollow vessel be prepaired
► Sign up to the Telegraph's free new daily newsletter, From the Editor, bringing you the latest news, features and analysis from the Telegraph newsroom: www.telegraph.co.uk/customer/secure/newsletter/from-the-editor/?WT.mc_id=tmgoff_youtube_telegraphmain
► Get the latest headlines: www.telegraph.co.uk?WT.mc_id=tmgoff_youtube_telegraphmain
Tedious interview.
► Stay ahead with a Telegraph digital subscription:
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/customer/subscription/store?WT.mc_id=tmgoff_youtube_telegraphmain
Great clarity and he also looks in great physical condition. Incredibly rare these days.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/ and https://www.youtube.com/telegraph are websites of The Telegraph, the UK's best-selling quality daily newspaper providing news and analysis on UK and world events, business, sport, lifestyle and culture.
The only thing Lord Case is missing is a Panama hat and a posting to some banana republic like the Central African Republic.
More User Perspectives
So this is the real Sir Humphrey. Teflon coated cardboard cut out who does not care about solving anything.
@georgep4465Starmer seemed nice well intentioned individual but weak spineless leader with low futuristic vision, more ideological than realistic.
@Pete-x9yStarmer would make capable Assistant Town Clerk (Acting) in a small sleepy council somewhere. More than that? Forget it
@latimeralder1This conversation needed Rupert Lowe as a third member.
@johnj4860Why does this guy always takes a nap before talking???
@artgonzalezhotmailPromoted way above his ability. I’m talking about Case as well as Starmer.
@oliverwells7367"When small men begin to cast big shadows, it means that the sun is about to set" - Lin Yutang. This is all I can think of when I hear from the people that are in the highest positions
@thepigofhappinessThe lefty blob has long and deep infiltration. The Fabian motto “wolf in sheep’s clothing “ is so true. A dangerous,destructive entity! Almost anarchistic.
@Cosmoscosmos1I’ve seen sterner librarians.
@Cosmoscosmos1The leftwing civil service is the absolute chronic Achilles heel of the uk.
@Cosmoscosmos1The interviewer is desperately trying to get his subject to diss Starmer, keeps asking loaded Qs, putting words in the mouth, distorting the answers, but Case remains his own man. It very much reminds me - mirror opposite, politically speaking - of Cathy Newman with Jordan Peterson.
@andrewashdown3541NO STATEMAN. Put him on the buses. A family man he dosent think of my family with these illegals on my doorstep. Yu hv them iam sure they be moved on. 2 tier keir
@DianeBonner-g3dJust a reminder that this was the real guy with hands on the levers of power for the last decade.
@_Titanium_Don't worry I'm sure Andy Burnham will be very well prepared - just read his wikipedia history!! He has never had any international experience apparently. Oh, and has he been properly vetted - does Labour learn from its mistakes?
@paulmasonsjazz9611There are many many civil servants simply coasting
Experts in keeping apparently busy and doing very very little
If Starmer was unprepared then Burnham must be totally unprepared. This does not bode well for the nation.
@EAZY-o6fThe blob is the enemy
@johnprime-w2nThe most inspiring thing here is the outfit.
@stevemallion5240I am coming to the conclusion that the Burnham ‘victory’ in Makerfield has been very carefully engineered by the state. A Cabinet Secretary of Mr Case’s stature wouldn’t speak ill of any PM unless advised to do so.
He is breaking a very old convention and one I cannot imagine anyone would sanction in normal circumstances.
Add to this the coronation of Burnham who has no plan, manifesto, ideas, policies or public approval then the whole thing seems incredibly contrived.
As usual the electorate get what they are given, satisfactory or not.
Starmer a family man? As in family of rent boys.
@diamondsbillSmug beta
@sirprancealott2003A very thoughtful listen and a great initiative to speak to Lord Case. It was startling to hear that the politicians did not want their departments to be cut to pre-COVID levels. The "half the size and double the pay" idea is a great idea as long as we don't then morph into a tight core team of civil servants being spoon fed by contractors and consultants.
More of these types of interviews, please.
500,000+ civil servants? And how many contractors on top of that?
@SimonAcors-it6trV interesting conversation.
@alexrafterStarmer is simply uncapable.
@yaulkwong3775Katie Hopkins for the next prime minister, it's the only logical solution.
@RussellKenny-y2mI think the problem is less the prime ministers but the fact Simon Case ever got to be cabinet secretary with so little experience or qualifications.
@djjs91Is this the best we’ve got?!
@MattyR472This guy was a Cabinet Secretary?!!
@LongerLastingGood interview. Seems an intelligent chap, a logical, structured thinker. Not a leader, an adviser...
@wb1956Labour had 15 years 😂😂😂😂😂
@Larrygerry-c9kIMO
Interview with Simom Case was too short.
A man in his former position, with his experience could have informed viewers of a greater in-depth understanding,
of the relationship between the Civil Service and successive governments,
especially, in light of
the recent sacking of the permanent under secretary (PUS) Sir Olly Robbins, at The Foreign Commonwealth and Devolopment Office. (FCDO)
in relation to the appointment of Peter Mandelson as the UK Ambassador to The US.
Starmer seemed out of touch with the expectations of the electorate. And as a result he made no decisions or bad decisions, pleasing no one.
@RobertMorris-ik9wyThese people coming out the woodwork is poor
@adamgrimsley2900Starmer can still hudle with Zelensky and Macron. They were a great team. Like the Three Stooges.
@X-GeronimoIts the choice of socks matched with the traditional Linen Suit! A foot in both Camps?
@robertattwood7505Interesting insights.
@dadanandaThanks for the insights.
@vseme1572If Starmer was unprepared, can we demand a refund? Why are we paying for lazy cretins?
@jstewart4205He's an 'AI adoption expert' now? Yet trots out the most banal, shallow and oblique anecdotes supported by 30,000ft snapshot data. Good grief.
@cconcannon5145Stop the boats... complex?
@--DaniThe blandness, the ineptitude and the whole failure of successive governments beautifully aided by this nonentity.
Depressing isn’t it!?
When he couldn’t put through the needed welfare reform he was dead. He obviously was not in charge.
@doc2146Starmer was either wittingly or not the Corbynite Trojan Horse. He'll be remembered as one of the worst enemies of British democracy and values.
@Swelter_ingThis man completely shocked the nation, by his total lack communication to the British elected,, day one of government administration,, saying things going get worse before they better, certainly true to his work,, who gives away sovereign British territory, plays hundreds of billions taxpayers money to anther nation,,, on the judgement of foreign court, totally bonkers,, just that alone is enough to sink any government
@edbaker515