the crimes of ryan murphy: a glee project deep dive
Video Overview & Insights
Shop Typology & receive a FREE Hydrating Cleansing Milk with your purchase of $40+, valid for 1 week after this video goes live! https://bit.ly/3VibzVi
I will just point out that baby it's cold outside is not at all a song that permotes concent in any way. In fact, in the OG version of the song the line, "Do you think this drink tastes funny," by the female part of the duo is sung. That fact, coupled with what happened surrounding the duet, is dan schnider levels of gross. Nobody but Ryan should be to blame for this. Murphy is for sure somebody to stay away from.
national domestic violence hotline: https://www.thehotline.org/
Melissa Benoist Interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QeNNIEak5iY
Glee is availlable to watch on hulu and disney plus. Which makes sense, given Disney's long, long history with people like Brian Peck, Ryan Murphy, and others. Aledgidly.
Glee Project Insider article: https://www.businessinsider.com/the-glee-project-behind-the-scenes-cast-interviews-oral-history-2022-8
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/AshleyNorton
Surprisingly (not a dig) lovely and charming summary of some not-so-lovely behaviour. Not sure how you’ve managed to keep me in a gentle trance while commentating on some pretty upsetting things, but you’ve done it by golly.
Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/extra_ashley
Insta: https://www.instagram.com/aaashleynorton
there was genuinely no point of that second season running if ryan was going to be as fixated on blake as he was. like genuinely to the point where the other people on the show tried to convince him to at least consider the others and give them a chance but he was too stubborn to admit that he already made up his mind from the start. he wasted everybody's time as if he wasn't just going to hand the win over to the boring pos he was obsessed with
Gaming Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@AshleyNortonGaming
Business Inquiries: ashleynorton@zigguratxyz.com
TIMESTAMPS
intro- 00:00:00
genuinely hilarious how obvious the cute male bias is looking back
typology- 00:04:10
the format- 00:05:28
ali came to talk at a school i worked at (#NewJerseyREPRESENT) and i still think she was so robbed. i watch this video to honor the fact she was robbed since i cannot watch these reality shows on my own.
season one- 00:12:11
season two- 00:42:38
the aftermath- 01:04:10
#typologyparispartner
I genuinely can't belive they cut out a 19yo's assault survivor's story, solely to make her look bad, then TRICKED HER INTO BEING A PERPETRATOR. That is WILD. Ryan Murphy has a special place in hell reserved for him, I swear.
what would you do for a 7 episode guest starring role on hit fox television show glee? The glee project was your typical cash grab reality show. Except these theater kids futures hinged entirely on whether ryan murphy felt inspired enough to write them a self insert character to rival kurt hummel. Pushing teenagers boundaries? tokenizing diverse contestants? mashups of milkshake and moves like jagger? all fair game in the world of ryan murphy.
the racialized aspect of them trying to force androgyny on abraham is craazzyyyy when you consider how often asian men are feminized and emasculated historically (and still to this day) in the west
More User Perspectives
As a kid I had a cut out of the word Klaine colored in rainbow tacked on my wall lmao 😭
@Madison-kh4bxThe random resurgence of Glee on YouTube is giving me life.
Okay, the random flash of Drew and Danny? 😂
I worked with the contestant Lindsay a few years after this show and she was an absolute sweetheart. When I recognized her she was so bashful, humble and a bit shy which I wouldn't have guessed based on the show edit. Crazy gorgeous in person too
@LEMATTOFFICIALTbh for the Cameron thing I think it would've been fair to just kick him off the show the moment he set up that kissing boundary. Fact of the matter is this is a teen drama and I don't believe for a second that Ryan Murphy actually wrote these characters for them so much as they were existing, already thought up characters or plotlines who he wanted to cast and was willing to make minor adjustments to. Given the premise and circumstances imo it'd be fair to reject him on the premises "This is also an acting gig and this is the type of show it is." The problem I have is just keeping him in the show just to assault him and try to make him break that boundary.
@iluvsnickers15561:00:27 I just threw up on my mouth. Thank you.
@ieatgremlins23:01 there are multiple photos of me as a young queer kid wearing 3D glasses with the lens popped out, including when I briefly lived in Texas. I feel called out lol
@blithesomeboyNo Ryan Murphy, Glee would have been nothing.
He is an ass. But, he knows what it takes to put out a great successful tv show. He wanted to show them that fame isn’t all fun and games. Yeah, he’s a prick but he made glee what it was
Jesus what the fuck was wrong with the people who made this show
@marshmallowcat188937:08 i think about the skidoosh theft probably once a month tbh
@alyssariceYT1:01:00 Considering Blake has domestic abuse allegations that he in 2020 took "full responsibility" for against his ex wife, Melissa Benoist, is interesting when watching this recap. The judges saying they finds Blake's portrayal very good is scary because of his later actions.
Side Note: Blake and Melissa meet on Glee
1:00:42 the way my face was involuntarily scrunched up the whole time he read his poem…. and the tears in Nicki’s eyes… i know they don’t have hindsight but it feels so icky now.
@liseyboop9:45 “it’s beautiful it’s amazing” the bed it’s taller than her wheelchair, there’s no way she didn’t struggle
@zfbkirk483225:13 dropping into this to say that i went to the same megachurch as cameron growing up and he was indeed well beloved and crushed on but the one memory i have of him was him walking around church camp with Toms and capri shorts on and i thought he looked a lot like mr tumnus from narnia w that fit
@lilo50101:01:11 the way he wasnt playing a character here....hes so scary
@WhatevziguessSo Ryan Murphy constantly sets up diverse characters against the white cishet characters he actually prefers to justify his preference toward them. I’ve never realized how insecure he is
@Wolfvonbiele9314:14 the way they made being irish his character's whole personality when he was on glee. his two traits were irish and horny
48:32 i'm not sure this was necessarily because charlie is autistic. he has ADHD, a major symptom of which is impulsivity. i suppose you could say the autism part was misreading social cues about what would be appropriate to do for the scene. it’s weird that they chose that take specifically.
15:52 I knew Alex was wrecking it on Broadway, but I was not prepared for hearing their voice on the last season of Hazbin Hotel. As soon as I heard their voice, I had to look it up lol
@paigew1311My uncle dated Ryan Murphy. I've met him when they were dating. He gave me the creeps; my uncle described their breakup as "being stalked by an ex who felt like he had the world at his fingertips... and kind of did".
@WiFightTheFeeling23:50 I will say, even the cut apart version doesn’t make her seem excessively vain to me? Like, feeling like you have to be what others want is valid.
I really respect Cameron for standing his ground and leaving, and it’s really scummy that when he expressed a desire to quit Ryan went “yeah, but I’m not done with you .”
Oh my god I remember seeing the ad at 22:44 on tumblr when I was 12-13 and being like “woooww….so deep….”
@dannyb9992Glee had Santana, Rachel, Kurt, Blaine, Finn.. but the newbies starting in S4 ruined it. Will was always bad 😂
@sugarshaz7854What the fuck was that slam poetry bro I never need to hear that again
@mayaraejohnsonRyan Murphy seems like the biggest hole of a man in every clip I see of him
@crowboycurtisThis is, seemingly, the most fake progressive show i have ever heard of. This feels like its on the same level of queer baiting, with hyping up how diverse and unique the cast is, before going out of their way to rig the generic white dude to win
@treymoney1019The insistence by the mentors that Abraham is “androgynous” REALLY feels like racist undertones. Emasculating Asian men and portraying them to be more feminine/passive/weak/ect. than other, non Asian men is unfortunately not uncommon.
It’s already uncomfortable to ask such a personal question like this on camera, but the potential racism really just makes it all the more awful.
Skidoosh is from Kung fu panda and the rid di di di de do is from the office they both stole it
@GbabyLewis-m3bOf course the white boy with dreadlocks was willing to steal Hannah’s rap style 😭😭
@GuntWastelanderWas recently helping my dad organize and was trying to find like the deed to our house, and it was dead ass in a gleek folder from 2012
@grace-dachshund1836:22 Ryan Murphy YOURE NOT EVEN FITTED!!
@no1diesfromlove🎀🌸 Just Like With The Late Naya Rivera, I Tear Up Every Time I See Cameron On This Show❣️ It’s So Sad What Happened To Him❣️ & Now I’m Starting To Have Second Thoughts On Whether Or Not I Wanna Keep Those Songs On My Spotify Playlist❣️ 🌸🎀
@BonBon42Abraham didn’t look queer at all
@cjpittman618936:49 okay but both of these kids stole that from Jack Black
@Deadspooky-GoreI didn’t watch Glee but for some reason was hooked on The Glee Project season 2. Justice for Nellie, she deserved better
@marinemanaphy101I am just obsessed with Ali I was just so happy she got her flowers getting her tony. Meant a lot to me as a disabled choir kid to see someone with such powerhouse vocals 😅
@redsmovieden42God I didn't realize how clearly I remembered the season 1 contestants. I haven't seen it since it was on, but it's like I saw them on screen yesterday.
@hellomello258Thank you for being up front about Blake in the video. Poor Melissa :(
@Ace7.0.740:09 sam is half mexican queen
@brennamorrison9921:38 I mean, that scene is a legitimate masterpiece
@neondeadlights5014IMAGINAL DISK!!!!!
@togepibatsupergirl was on glee????
@hp8685