free web page hit counter
🛡️
Copyright Notice: This video is officially sourced and embedded from YouTube. For all copyright inquiries, reports, or removals, please contact YouTube's legal team here.
Y Reviews

Y Reviews

57,000 subscribers

⏱ 👁 330,097 views

Why CGI Feels Boring Now

Video Overview & Insights

Lately, CGI in movies has been feeling pretty boring. It used to be amazing in Iron-Man, Avatar, Jurassic Park, Planet of the Apes, Transformers, Pirates of the Caribbean, and Lord of the Rings. Now, whether it's a one-dimensional villain in a new comic book movie or a giant monster exploding out of the ground, audiences have become desensitized to the sheer volume of CGI and VFX out there. Let's talk about where it all went wrong.

It feels like most things in this world are getting worse.

— @BrokeYuTuber

00:00 Intro

00:32 It's All Disney's Fault

The nanobot Ironman suit doesn't feel like it has any weight to it. Definitely not as cool visually

— @lilred5515

02:59 We Used To Film Things For Real

05:06 The Friggin' Volume

There are examples of bad CGI from the golden years. The tintin movie polar Express.

— @c1a2t3a4p5i6l7l8a9r

07:04 Emotions Before Explosions

09:15 People Have Gotten Pickier

I think that the only Jurassic film that really suffers from bad CGI is JP3 since most of it is during the day so it makes the flaws easier to see compared to Lost World where the only day scenes with CGI Dinos are the Stegos, the Hunter stampede, and the ending shot. JP also had a lot of day shots with CGI, but far fewer of them overall, allowing more time for the animators to work on them. And once we got to World, the CGI was finally good enough for all the day scenes. Same with Fallen Kingdom and Dominion especially with how they did the feathered Dinosaurs. Rebirth then continued the trend of the saga having great CGI.

— @DinoFan8

Tracks:

Branch by Lukrembo

So basically the studios have gotten lazy 🤷🏻‍♂️

— @hunteraleman4934

Rose Water by Massobeats

Faithful Mission by Artificial Music

Holy shit. That cut of Tony's head being inside the CGI suit looks like something from that SPY Kids: Game Over movie. This is Disney/Marvel at it's finest.

— @AshleyKrowed199

Zaza produced by Danya Vodovoz / Royalty Free Music

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJkBEUXoExg

no cgi is really bad look at mcu early movies felt like real

— @RubulTanti153

Let That Sink In produced by Danya Vodovoz / Royalty Free Music

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JM_CfMzkvU

Avatar 3 proved that peakn CGI is still alive

— @ShErad23

Toilet Paper produced by Danya Vodovoz / Royalty Free Music

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8kbsH_cqzwE

CGI feels boring because it IS boring. I'm old enough to remember when we'd go to a movie and wonder how the hell they did that. Who wonders now?

— @williamleavy9536

Mayonnaise produced by Danya Vodovoz / Royalty Free Music

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Ui-Wj7mL3Q

Because people are fed up with fake everything. We want real stuff.

— @fangirling-y5y

More User Perspectives

@

Yes!!!!! I don’t f-king get it anymore and it’s not just CGI storytelling, acting, realism, and relatability all went to
sh!t especially for Disney I mean lord!!!!

@Jordan-Tait-7
@

So the mother of films for modern audiences is "Iron Man". Well...

@nickfit-u4o
@

even the good modern cgi feels somewhat off tho

@hoshiskur
@

To be honest, I only clicked on this video because I saw optimus.

@Unbreaking_prime
@

the only time I accepted and liked cgi was Pacific Rim 1. They made it somehow feel weighty and it complemented the story

@rosewatersaffron8430
@

Because it is 30 years old and over used.

@THCPublishing
@

Yup. You can pretty much walk into a movie nowadays expecting some sort of CGI, whether it's from Hollywood or even from China.

@hungchoonghow5857
@

But honestly, the VFX in the Avatar series is still top-tier. In TWOW and Fire and Ash, the effects are so insanely realistic that you can't even tell what's CGI and what’s actually real. Even though CGI is supposed to support the story rather than replace it, it plays a huge role in leveling up the whole movie-watching experience.

@AlwaysGrateful-oc5iw
@

Because CGI is being used in literally all the movies nowadays so it has lost the wow factor the skill used to carry earlier.

@cse0355
@

"Negativity was kept in check because there wasn't a million different outlets"
well said

@TheBauerman51
@

Maybe you just growing up and these things are below your range now.

@RSyoungF
@

😂Liar, you are a liar, sir.😂

@RealismAG
@

The artists are also underpaid and never given enough time or recognition

@TheRoboBlazerz
@

thats why nolan movies feel real

@christopher_trou
@

Cgi is for nuance and hiding mistakes, old cinephiles have always been preaching about how bad cgi is

@Huemandoin65
@

I feel like its also because theyre using unreal engine now so it literally just looks like video game cutscenes.

@IKIGAIofficial
@

In response to the title - the human brain can’t continuously process images that defy physics and nature. It’s fun here and there but not all the time.

@MichaelM-p7u
@

CGI is not the problem. The problem is that movies are about making profits anymore. When was the last time you saw a movie that brought you into the story? When was the last time you were genuinely curious or empathetic to a character? Exactly. Movies don't really guide you through the story anymore, they're CGI slop with badly written characters.

@wogelson
@

Fair points

@Aditya-tx3zc
@

Excellent essay and flawless criticism of the current state of the artform. VFX artists are some of the most talented artists in history, but they are pushed to impossible lengths under short deadlines on razor thin bugets. Filmmakers who understand how to use their tools will always deliver magical memorable experiences.

@Couple-O-Ghosts
@

04:41 What do you mean the room isn't even real? 😭😭😭 Aowa guys, green screen even for a regular set 😭😭😭 yoh bathong!

@CabblowStudios
@

4:48 bro she just doesn't remember him thats all.

@AsuraTheHunter
@

Godzilla Minus One CGI looks 10/10 and you care for the characters.

@Wolfman-hw8yt
@

Nothing will ever get close to how LOTR looked and Davy Jones.

@CelebrityLyrics
@

I think directors are the keystone visual effects get better. few directors has a hands input Steven Spielberg, Guillermo del Toro, Michael Bay I think that's why they have put great input. and industry it self like animation brutal deadlines and low pay

@naminda92
@

Ahhhhhhhhhh when Ceasar yelled NO. Man that hit hard when I first watched it!

@redswords4295
@

This is why I don’t like cgi. It’s become their only medium. Whenever I watch a series or movie, I always believe what I see but when everything is green screen I don’t believe it and then I don’t enjoy it. Just take the recent anaconda movie with Jack black and Paul Rudd. They actually filmed on location! (So impressive!) but then they used the worst cgi for the snake, and instead of mixing practical effects, they just gave us a shitty cgi snake. I know it’s a meta comedy, but what if instead of showing a shitty snake rendition, they could’ve used ripples in the water, filmed from the snakes pov, or like used a sock puppet. Anything to make it tangible, but no, they go with over-telling and bad graphics

@heinanX
@

CGI is part of the problem, but the main problem is still bad story telling. Writers are mentally bankrupt, no new ideas.

@ryszardarckontte4736
@

We will see worse...AI coming....!

@dovlaksimus2640
@

11:16 did anyone find that offensive and very inconsiderate of the protest going on that day? the man was right, she looked like she was mocking at that speech, hollyweird or holly I don't fucking care about your rights I am rich.

@cunbinzhg
@

It's boring because we're used to quality of effects - there's no effect WOW now days - there are no special effects that couldn't be created today

@dapolcio3405
@

I saw a lot of people talk about how over used CGI is today in movies and looks worse than movies made 30 years ago. Well I watched Creed 2 a few weeks ago, a film I hadn’t watched since it came out. I was shocked how bad the fight looked in my second viewing, it was like an animated Video game, it’s bad already. Then I thought about how the Rocky fights still look great but are like 40 plus years old. So it’s 100% right, this digital rubbish now, is going to make modern movies age poorly in the future compared to much older movies. That’s because in Rocky they are pretending to fight and that’s real, in Creed it’s CGI, Computer Animations and only some real. That’s why Back To The Future, Terminator 2, Titanic, Lord Of The Rings, Matrix etc all still look great.

@tonydew440
@

Cameron is Liar the "Idea" of Avatar is copy paste oldschool game named Albion... he stolen it

@prolamer7
@

The answer is simple, CGI used to be for achieving realism and realism is no longer the focus of modern movies with CGI spectacle.

@falco5150
@

I actually thought that this video will tackle the issue of most CGI being made with UE5, nowadays. Gore Verbinski criticized the fact that most of the big players have started using UE5 and this is why most of the movies have a gaming aesthetic to them, rather than that close to realism feeling you would get (remember the CGI from Pirates of the Caribbean?). Traditional rendering, done by established names in the industry was, is and will remain centuries ahead of what you can achieve, in the present, with UE5. So after watching this video (and wasting a good quarter of an hour of my life) i realized that this is not why CGI feels boring now but rather a random rant of someone who mistakenly confuses bad CGI with bad story telling.

@kuzia1984
@

Guys! Why when click like on this video the like animation is different? When did this happen?

@ektonas
@

I still can't believe how good the CGI in the prehistoric planet series has been. Really puts most stuff out there at the moment to shame.

@jackslater5886
@

Please do a video on why there's no pop out 3D effect on movies nowadays😢😢😢😢

@chithradevi2942
@

Yoooooooooooooooo

@andrethomas6183
@

At least Sonic 3 is good

@AzAnimates